West End
Authors: Aoi, Futaba and Kurenai, Mitsuba
Published by: Biblos
Serialized in: BeXBoy Gold
Currently 4 volumes, still running. CDs available. No OAVs/movies as of this date.
~Reviewed by Nora
Burning out? Getting tired of the run-of-the-mill? Need
a new direction? Tired of smut tales with all-too-predictable plots? Tired of complicated
plots with no smut? Want to think, without thinking? Want your flying bodily fluids
to actually exist for a reason? Like to see a little blood fly, too?
Then "West End" (WE) just might be for you. Not for the squeamish,
this futuristic existential sex opera---the story abounds with rape, murder (up close and
personal), abuse, angst, torture, shots of previously internal organs, melting people,
genetic engineering run rampant, amputation, and all sorts of other lovely items. It comes
with the territory, given the sci-fi series concept, but don't expect the sort of tender
romance that appears in "Level C," another yaoi series created by the same
authors. Whenever tender romance does appear in this series, it always has a darker side.
"Dark" describes WE perfectly. Many years after the world has
been blown to nuclear hell, the society that has arisen from the ashes is starkly
stratified, borderline anarchic, and matter-of-factly violent. Some semblance of
society survives---the world seems to be composed now of a single, unattractive, sprawling
city, with a few nice areas but mostly just seedy places and slums. Anyone with a
half-developed sense of self-preservation goes armed; there is no law. Because so many
people (particularly women, apparently) were killed in the war, a new species of
artificial human was created to serve as a labor class. The "Demiuri," as they
are called (more frequently abbreviated as "Demi"), do all of the dirty work of
society, from the dangerous to the just plain undesirable---including serving the sexual
needs of anyone who happens to want them. They're the perfect slaves and sex
slaves---universally kawaii, universally submissive, and for the most part eager to please
(helps that they all have a handy-dandy adaptation for their role: the self-lubricating
anus). And disposable. A Demi's lot in life is generally sad; they're considered to be
only a step above animals despite their obvious intelligence, and are regularly
mistreated. They're kept in line by means of a simple, if disturbing, control: if they
don't ingest a combination of drugs every day, they die. Horribly, but I won't go into the
details.
Enter Tonami, an exceptionally pretty young Demi whom the reader first meets
as he's being gang-screwed by three men and taunted that if he doesn't satisfy all of
them, he won't get his pills for the day. Tonami performs to expectation, and thus the
tone for the entire series is set. "West End" is Tonami's tale---the tale of a
sensitive, emotional, self-aware slave in a society where anyone powerless, especially
with such a gentle spirit, is pretty much doomed to misery. Most of the Demis are said to
have no emotions, but Tonami is a clear exception, in part because he's a Castle Demi, a
special high-quality type of Demi who was raised in comfort and privilege to become a
consort of the wealthy (he was kidnapped by unsavory types, which is how he ended up
living the sad life of a lower-class Demi). He is the lens through which the society of
"West End" is seen, and it is him through whom the reader considers questions
about the morality of slavery and the corruption of technological society--- questions
that few other people, in "West End", seem to be asking.
Especially not Kiri, the human who steals Tonami away from the factory
that owns him at the beginning of the story. Kiri seems at first to be a typical young man
of his world: vicious, sadistic, an expert with a knife, cold-hearted and exploitative,
charming when he needs to be, crude and cruel when he doesn't. Yet there's something about
him (cue music) that attracts Tonami from the very beginning. Could it be his eyes? Or
could it be that Tonami senses the strange idealism in this hardened street-brawler, which
even Kiri doesn't seem to understand?
Kiri wants to go west. Even he doesn't seem to know why, but he's
determined to get there, and he's too ruthless to let a little thing like morality get in
his way. After spiriting Tonami away from the factory (to, Tonami innocently hopes, a
better life), Kiri reveals his baser intent; he wanted Tonami for both his own sexual
gratification and for easy cash, which he gets by prostituting Tonami and using the
proceeds to finance their journey.
Tonami, suffering and submissive traditional Japanese female allegory
that he is, endures this and a whole host of worse trials, because he loves Kiri. And Kiri
loves Tonami---quite against his will. The relationship between the two becomes extremely
abusive at times, as Kiri attempts to prove to himself and to Tonami that he would never
stoop low enough to love a Demi. He plays it off whenever he rescues Tonami from danger,
occasionally even risking his life to do so; he's just "taking care of his
property." Tonami doesn't know whether Kiri loves him or not, but he's determined to
love Kiri anyway, in the hope that love will change his master. And so the co-dependence
develops.
All unpleasantness aside, what's really interesting about WE are the
numerous mysteries that crop up as the series progresses. Kiri, we learn, is as
extraordinary among humans as Tonami is among Demis, but the reader is given only
tantalizing glimpses of his apparently traumatic and frightening past. Tonami is important
enough that several mysterious and powerful figures are looking for him---for what
purpose, and why he's so important, we don't know. And then there's the mystery of the
Demiuri themselves. Do they have any hope of freedom? Why is Tonami so different from the
rest? And just how Human are they?
"West End" makes grand efforts at examining
deep, complex themes involving society and the individual, love and sex, technology and
morality, and the meaning of "humanity." Unfortunately, sometimes it goes way
past "deep" and edges into just plain silly. I'm probably expecting too much
logic from this series, but that's probably because I'm a Western science fiction fan and
this is Japanese sci-fi---in other words, it looks great and is interesting, but it
doesn't necessarily make sense to the Western-trained mind. For example: because most of
the Demiuri look like pretty young boys, the reader is essentially presented with an
entire race of weepy ukes. Are we to believe that in the shortage of women, every man on
the planet became gay (and seme and shotacon, at that)? Nobody wanted female Demis, or
human ukes? Nobody wants more manly, or older-looking, sex slaves? And why weren't bigger,
stronger Demis developed for physical labor? How much work can a
98-pound weakling do?
Okay, I know, I know, it's yaoi. It doesn't have to make sense, as
long as it looks/feels good.
But come on.
The complete lack of logic isn't the worst flaw in the series; the story's
not over, so it may eventually start to make sense. Whether the art of WE looks good
enough to make up for the story's confusion is a matter of personal taste; I found WE's
art attractive and interesting, if disproportional and a bit stilted and stark---which
fits the setting. What I found most annoying about WE was that the extreme pathos
of the Demiuri became frustrating after a while. They're almost constantly depicted as
miserable and abused, which I assume is meant to make the reader pity their downtrodden
plight---but the sheer magnetite of suffering that they endure is sometimes so horrific
that one wonders why they don't just collectively commit suicide.
It's an interesting sci-fi twist on the usual yaoi themes, with a
surprising philosophical undercurrent. Make no mistake, however---this is yaoi. Somebody
gets laid in every chapter, sometimes consensual, usually not, always graphically and
taking up several pages. There are enough flying bodily fluids to cause a small flood. The
Demis are borderline shota---most are supposed to be in their mid-teens, but some are
younger; none are older. Every guy has a vaguely cylinder-shaped drippy thing between his
legs. The Demis always cry (sometimes understandably). And the uke-as-allegorical-woman
cliche gets done into
the ground. It's no wonder that the few women seen in the series don't seem to be in any
particular demand, despite their rarity---who needs a real woman when you can have your
very own submissive, pretty, self-lubricating, weepy, overly emotional, weak
playmate/servant, who won't talk back?
My recommendation: if you can handle nonconsensual sex (frequently),
violence (lots), gore (buckets), and angst (many Kleenex), there's actually a story here
that's worth reading. Particularly for the sci-fi or mystery fan. As for the romance
fan---if you think Minami Ozaki's works are the most romantic thing since "Gone With
The Wind," you'll dig Kiri and Tonami. PWP fans---ignore the plot; there's more than
enough graphic sex to keep you happy. Budding psychoanalysts---Kiri and Tonami
are thesis material. Anyone looking for realism of plot, relationship or setting, or sweet
and tender love scenes and theme... I think there's a little sweetness in Book 3, for a
few pages. Otherwise, look elsewhere.